Police Investigations: Should I Obtain Criminal Defense Attorney Representation?
“Should I consult with an attorney, or hire an attorney, if I am being investigated by the police for a criminal offense?” The answer is yes, and yes again. You should not speak to police officers, detectives, or federal agents before consulting with an experienced criminal defense attorney. In my almost two decades of criminal defense practice, I have successfully prevented felony and misdemeanor charges from being filed against my clients on multiple occasions through early intervention during police investigations of my clients.
Everything you say to the police can and will be used against you as law enforcement officers build a criminal case. This includes conversations with officers at the scene of the incident, over the phone, by text or email, in your home, outside your home, and at the police station. This holds for Alexandria, Fairfax, and Arlington, as well as federal agents and investigators in Virginia and Washington, D.C.

Attorney Representation During Police Investigations
Case Results
DISCLAIMER: ATTORNEY CASE RESULTS DEPEND ON FACTORS UNIQUE TO EACH CASE AND CANNOT PREDICT NOR GUARANTEE RESULTS FOR FUTURE CLIENTS.
Non-Custodial Police Questioning & Why Miranda Warnings Do Not Apply
Just because an officer did not read you your Miranda rights does not mean your statements cannot be used against you. The rules governing Miranda warnings apply only when police are questioning you while you are in custody, such as when you are under arrest or not free to leave. When a detective calls you on the phone, knocks on your front door, or asks you to come to the station for a “voluntary interview,” Miranda warnings are not required, yet every word you say is recorded as evidence. You can read more below about Miranda rights and constitutional protections against self-incrimination.
Miranda Rights and Self Incrimination Explained by Virginia Criminal Defense Attorney
Remember, a police officer or federal agent’s job is to investigate incidents, bring charges, and arrest suspects. Their job is not to help you. Officers use legal interrogation tactics to get information from you, tactics that lead to charges and convictions based on your own cooperation. These tactics range from acting supportive and reassuring, to intimidating you with threats of arrest, to scaring you by accusing loved ones or friends of the crime and offering you a chance to protect them by incriminating yourself.
Furthermore, in a federal investigation, making a materially false or misleading statement to a federal agent, even during an informal, unsworn interview at your home or over the phone, is an independent federal felony under 18 U.S.C. § 1001, punishable by up to 5 years in federal prison even if the underlying investigation never results in charges.
What Will My Attorney Do During the Police Investigation?
First, your attorney can invoke your constitutional right to remain silent and right to counsel so police detectives and federal agents direct all communications through your lawyer rather than contacting or questioning you directly. From there, your defense lawyer can investigate the case, communicate with the police, detectives, or federal agents on your behalf when appropriate, and determine how best to proceed. Every case is unique and requires its own strategy. In some cases, cooperation might be the best course of action. In others, complete silence is the smarter approach. And sometimes, a carefully balanced combination of both tactics is most effective.
Some pre-charge defense discussions with your lawyer may include:
- Invoking Your Right to Remain Silent & Stopping Direct Police Contact: Once you retain counsel, your defense attorney notifies the investigating detective or federal agent of your representation and invokes your Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination, shielding you from surprise phone calls, home visits, or pressured interviews.
- Evaluating Search Warrants, Subpoenas & Target Letters: Determining whether law enforcement is treating you as a witness, a subject, or the target of an investigation, and reviewing any search warrants, grand jury subpoenas, or digital device seizures, helps clarify your legal exposure before any charging decision is made.
- Conducting an Independent Defense Investigation & Preserving Evidence: Gathering favorable text messages, emails, financial records, surveillance video, and witness statements early in the investigation ensures critical evidence is preserved and evaluated by counsel first.
- Pre-Charge Representation With Detectives and Prosecutors: When the facts and evidence support it, your defense lawyer can present exculpatory context or legal defenses to detectives, Commonwealth’s Attorneys, or Assistant United States Attorneys prior to an arrest warrant or indictment being sought.
However, each case is unique and the review of your case facts requires serious attorney review and consideration.
If you have been contacted by a police detective or federal agent in Alexandria, Fairfax, Arlington, or Washington, D.C., contact MEDVIN LAW to consult with an experienced criminal defense attorney who can evaluate the evidence and advise on your potential defenses and mitigation options.
Virginia Police Departments
MEDVIN LAW has experience with Northern Virginia police departments:
- City of Alexandria Police Department
- Fairfax County Police Department
- City of Fairfax Police
- Arlington County Police Department
- City of Falls Church Police
- Town of Vienna Police Department
- Virginia State Police
- Virginia Department of Wildlife Resources
Federal Agencies
MEDVIN LAW has experience with federal law enforcement agencies:
- FBI
- DEA
- DOJ
- Pentagon Police, The Pentagon Force Protection Agency
- United States Park Police
- CIA
- ICE
- DHS FPS
Common Types of Charges Investigated by Police Officers and Federal Agents
- Embezzlement and Fraud, False Pretenses & Forgery
- Hit and Run
- Drug Distribution and Possession with Intent to Distribute
- Federal Conspiracy Charges and Virginia Criminal Conspiracy Charges: Drug Distribution, Wire Fraud, and Larceny
- Assault and Battery and Malicious Wounding
- Teenage Sexting Charges
- Date Rape Accusations, Sexual Assault, and Sexual Battery
- Internet Crimes and Computer Hacking Investigations
- Arson and Malicious Burning
- Reckless Discharge of a Firearm and Hunting Violations
- Unlawful Use of Force and Self-Defense Investigations
- Political Crimes and Election Fraud: MEDVIN LAW has defended both Democrat and Republican politicians





